REALTOR® · SRES® · KW On The Water Sarasota

Erica Smentowski

Your Gulf Coast
Home Awaits.

Sarasota · Bradenton · Longboat Key · Venice
and the communities in between.

SRES® Certified Senior Real Estate Specialist — expert guidance for the 50+ community

Buying, Selling, or Both

From first-time buyers to relocating families, snowbirds to sellers navigating complex situations — I'll guide you through every step.

Buying a Home

Whether you're relocating from out of state or searching for your Florida escape, I'll help you find the right community, negotiate confidently, and close without surprises.

Browse active listings →

Selling Your Home

Backed by KW's nationwide marketing platform, I'll price your home strategically, reach thousands of buyers, and guide the transaction all the way to a smooth closing.

Request a listing consultation →

Home Valuation

Curious what your home is worth in today's Gulf Coast market? Get a free, no-obligation valuation — with real local context, not just an algorithm.

Get your home value →

55+ & Senior Buyers

As an SRES®-certified agent, I specialize in the unique considerations of the 50+ market — HOA requirements, estate sales, downsizing, and 55+ communities throughout the Gulf Coast.

Talk to Erica →

Relocation

Moving to Florida from out of state? I've helped buyers from New England, the Midwest, and beyond find the right neighborhood without ever second-guessing their decision.

Start your relocation search →

Complex Transactions

Storm-damaged properties, co-op closings, FSBO purchases, estate sales — I've navigated them all. When the situation is complicated, experience matters most.

Discuss your situation →

The Gulf Coast, Corner to Corner

From Manatee County to Charlotte County — waterfront condos, inland communities, beach towns, and everything in between.

What Clients Say

Real reviews from real buyers and sellers across the Gulf Coast.

★★★★★

"My husband and I were quite impressed with Erica's knowledge and professionalism. In a few days visit she showed us many options within our price range. When we narrowed it down, she remembered to ask the difficult questions we wouldn't have thought of."

Dean & Sherry

Venice, FL · 2025

★★★★★

"Erica represented me on a for-sale-by-owner purchase and was incredibly thorough. The property was a post-hurricane renovation in a co-op — she anticipated the challenges and guided the process all the way through to a successful close."

Happy Beach House Buyer

Longboat Key, FL · 2025

★★★★★

"We purchased our seasonal home from out of state, and the experience was exceptional. Her in-depth knowledge of Florida communities and consistent market updates gave us confidence at every step of the process."

Linda V

Venice, FL · 2025

★★★★★

"Erica went way beyond expectations helping us sell our hurricane-damaged home. She arranged cleaning services and showed the property without power or air conditioning — always keeping us encouraged and informed throughout."

Susan R

Longboat Key, FL · 2025

★★★★★

"She guided us through the requirements of a 55+ HOA and the challenges of a distressed property. Knowledgeable, responsive, and detail-oriented — her calm demeanor made a complex transaction feel seamless."

Mark & Anne V

Longboat Key, FL · 2025

★★★★★

"A lot of stress comes with buying your first home and Erica made the entire process as seamless as possible. She walked us through every part start to finish. She communicates well and we will definitely use her again."

Blake & Kendra H

South Venice, FL · 2024

★★★★★

"My transaction was a difficult one — I was selling the house of my sister who had just passed away. Erica treated me like family, with compassion. I don't think anyone else could have completed the sale with as much care."

Donna F

South Venice, FL · 2024

★★★★★

"We are first-time snowbirds on a budget. We found a great turnkey condo within five days and closed within a month. Very professional, gave great advice. We highly recommend her."

Sue & Steven M

Venice, FL · 2024

★★★★★

"She spent an entire weekend looking at houses with us on short notice. She even attended both the inspection and closing on our behalf when we couldn't make it back down. A very special experience."

Frank & Brandy A

Englewood, FL · 2024

Leave a Review
Erica Smentowski, REALTOR® with Keller Williams On The Water Sarasota

Dedicated to Your Best Outcome

When you work with me, you get a knowledgeable and professional REALTOR® who is a committed ally — someone who negotiates on your behalf and tells you what you need to know, not just what you want to hear.

I serve buyers and sellers throughout the Sarasota–Bradenton metro, from Longboat Key and the barrier islands to inland communities like Lakewood Ranch, Parrish, and Venice. Whether your situation is straightforward or genuinely complex — a storm-damaged property, a co-op closing, an out-of-state purchase — I've navigated it before, and I'll navigate it for you.

I'm a licensed REALTOR® with Keller Williams On The Water in Sarasota and hold the SRES® designation (Senior Real Estate Specialist), with additional training in the unique needs of the 50+ market, including 55+ HOA requirements, downsizing, and estate transactions.

Full Bio on KW SRES® Senior Real Estate Specialist

Let's Talk About Your Goals

Whether you're buying, selling, or just beginning to explore — reach out and let's have a conversation.

941-704-0611 EricaSellsFL@kw.com 1549 Ringling Blvd Suite 600, Sarasota FL 34236